A Cardinal guide to Madison’s best holiday gifts

Between finals, frigid temperatures and end-of-semester fatigue, holiday shopping can feel like just another item on an already packed to-do list. But Madison’s local shops make it possible to give gifts that are thoughtful, affordable and rooted in the city without resorting to last-minute online orders. 

From under $15 stocking stuffers to experience gifts that last beyond winter break, here’s The Daily Cardinal’s guide to Madison-made holiday gifts. 

STATE STREET STAPLES (Under $30)

For quick, walkable shopping near campus, State Street offers plenty of budget friendly options. 

Anthology – For shoppers looking for small gifts that still feel intentional, Anthology offers a thoughtfully curated selection for every person in your life.

The shop features an eclectic mix of home decor, stationery, candles and accessories, alongside unique items like art prints and desk pieces. Many of the store’s most popular gifts fall in the $10-$30 range, making it a go-to stop for stocking stuffers, Secret Santa exchanges or last-minute roommate gifts.

Anthology emphasizes playful design and personality. Their Madison-centric holiday cards feature local landmarks like the Capitol and the iconic Memorial Union Terrace chairs making even the simplest items feel personal. Its central State Street location also makes it an accessible stop for students looking to shop local between classes.

Raygun – Though new to the Madison shopping scene, Raygun presents itself as the perfect gift buying location, especially for the jokester in your life. 

Raygun is known for its screen-printed t-shirts, sweatshirts and accessories that blend Midwestern identity with sharp, self-aware humor. The shop’s “Putting the sin back in Wisconsin” shirt is the perfect gift for your most mischievous Wisconsin loving friends. 

For out-of-state family members or recent graduates, Raygun’s Madison-themed designs offer a wearable reminder of life in Wisconsin — equal parts nostalgic and playful.

Raygun’s apparel typically ranges from around $24 to $60, making it an accessible option for students shopping for siblings, friends or themselves. Beyond clothing, the store also carries mugs, stickers and tote bags that work well as stocking stuffers or small add-ons.

Art Gecko State – For gifts that feel one-of-a-kind, Art Gecko offers an eclectic mix of handmade art and accessories.

The shop features work from local and regional artists, including jewelry, ceramics, prints and wearable pieces that lean bold and expressive. Shoppers can find statement earrings, rings and small art objects at a range of price points, with many items under $40 — making it an accessible stop for meaningful gifts that still feel special. Pendants and rings made with their “Stone of the Month” are 20% off this December — the perfect option if you’re a last minute deal-seeker.

Art Gecko’s selection favors individuality over trends, appealing to recipients who value creativity and craftsmanship. For students shopping for artists, designers or anyone with a distinctive sense of style, the store provides an alternative to mass-produced gifts.

WISCONSIN MADE FOOD GIFTS 

Edible gifts will always be a reliable option — especially when they highlight Wisconsin producers. 

Wisconsin Cheese Mart – For a gift that feels unmistakably Wisconsin, Wisconsin Cheese Mart delivers a local classic.

The shop offers an extensive selection of Wisconsin-made cheeses — from aged cheddars and squeaky fresh curds to specialty varieties infused with herbs, spices or beer. If you’re looking to splurge, Cheese Mart offers gift crates like their Wine Connoisseur Cheese Crate, combining five different varieties and priced at $56. Many items are also available in small portions, making it easy to build a custom gift without overspending.

Beyond cheese, the store also carries crackers, sausages and other complementary snacks, allowing shoppers to assemble a simple, travel-friendly gift for family members or hosts. Prices vary by selection, but most offerings are accessible for student budgets while still feeling elevated.

For out-of-state relatives, alumni or anyone who associates Madison with dairy pride, a stop at Wisconsin Cheese Mart provides a flavorful reminder of Wisconsin — no gift wrap required.

Orange Tree Imports – For practical gifts that still feel elevated, Orange Tree Imports remains a reliable favorite.

The store carries a wide selection of kitchen tools, bakeware, spices and specialty ingredients, alongside Wisconsin-made products like maple syrup and gourmet food items. Many giftable pieces — including mugs, spatulas and spice blends — fall within the $10-$30 range.

Orange Tree Imports is especially useful for shoppers looking to give something functional without sacrificing personality. Its mix of everyday kitchen essentials and specialty finds makes it an easy stop for parents, recent graduates or anyone settling into a new apartment.

EXPERIENCE GIFTS AROUND MADISON 

For those who already “have everything,” experiences offer something more memorable. 

Food Fight gift cards – For a flexible gift that still feels local, Food Fight gift cards offer access to some of Madison’s most popular restaurants.

Valid at more than 20 locally-owned establishments across the city, Food Fight cards allow recipients to choose their own dining experience — whether that means a casual brunch, a quick lunch or a sit-down dinner. Gift cards are available in a range of amounts, making them an easy option for students shopping on a budget or families looking for something universally useful.

For recipients who enjoy exploring Madison’s food scene, Food Fight gift cards turn a meal into an experience without requiring the gift giver to pick the restaurant.

Local art and pottery classes – For a gift that lasts beyond the holiday season, local art and pottery classes offer a hands-on experience rooted in Madison’s creative community.

Studios such as The Kiln Shed on Monroe Street and Wheelhouse Studios downtown offer one-day workshops and multi-week classes in wheel throwing, hand-building and glazing. Other studios around Madison also host painting and jewelry-making sessions, many designed for beginners with no prior experience required.

These classes appeal to students, couples and friends looking for a shared winter activity, as well as individuals interested in learning a new skill during the colder months. Perfect for grey Madison January days!

The Orpheum – For a holiday gift that keeps on giving into the new year, tickets to shows at Madison’s Orpheum Theater make a memorable present. Upcoming shows include multiple nights with comedy star John Mulaney in January and Kamala Harris’ book tour in March.

Tickets to Orpheum shows vary by performer and date, offering options for different tastes and budgets. 

The Overture – Tickets to performances at Overture Center for the Arts make memorable presents as well. Upcoming shows include Broadway’s biggest hit Hamilton and Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 in concert in January. 

Beyond Broadway, the Overture Center’s mix of shows include jazz, classical and family-friendly events, making it easy to find something for everyone on your list.

Tickets to shows vary by performance, giving gifters flexibility across budgets and interests. Whether it’s a night of theater, orchestral magic or a beloved musical reboot, Overture shows are perfect for a thoughtful, experiential holiday gift.

Shops like Little Luxuries and the University of Wisconsin Bookstore carry Madison skyline prints, map art and UW-inspired pieces that make popular gifts for alumni and graduating seniors. These items often double as dorm or apartment decor, making them both practical and sentimental. 

Beyond finding unique gifts, shopping locally keeps money in the Madison community — supporting artists, shop owners and workers who make the city what it is. For students shopping on a budget or families searching for something personal, Madison’s local stores offer a reminder that the best gifts don’t need to be shipped — they’re already here.

---