The University of Wisconsin-Madison announced on June 21, 2025, a lawsuit against the University of Miami for tampering with and ultimately poaching defensive back Xavier Lucas from their roster in violation of a name, image and likeness (NIL) agreement.
Wisconsin alleges Miami engaged in impermissible contact days after Lucas, a Florida native, entered an NIL contract with the Badgers, citing an alleged meeting between the defensive back and Miami coaches and alumni at his Florida home.
Although UW-Madison has not taken any legal action against Lucas himself, his lawyer claims Wisconsin was the problem for refusing to enter his name into the transfer portal. Wisconsin cites Lucas’ two-year long contractual NIL deal as the reason for this refusal.
“The University of Wisconsin-Madison remains committed to ensuring integrity and fundamental fairness in the evolving landscape of college athletics. After reviewing all facts and evaluating options, the university today filed a complaint in Wisconsin state court outlining our allegations against the University of Miami,” the school announced in a statement.
The university said it launched the lawsuit “reluctantly,” but believes enforcing NIL contracts like this one is “essential to maintaining a legal playing field” in the NCAA.
The results of this case have yet to play out, but are likely to have a broad impact on the landscape of NIL deals. This is the first time the financial and contractual obligations of an NIL deal have risen to this level of enforcement, so the case’s outcome will set a precedent for the future of student athletes' rights.
