Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
The Daily Cardinal Est. 1892
Thursday, June 20, 2024

Letter to the Editor: We need better policing, not less policing

The murder of George Floyd at the hands of the Minneapolis Police Department, and the riots and protests that have followed, have forged an essential discussion on police brutality that has been long in the making. In the past, many of us have responded to publicized incidents of police brutality by giving officers the benefit of the doubt because we believe that the other side of the story will justify their actions. We must now reckon, however, that the "other side of the story" does not always absolve police officers' of wrongdoing. For the first time, many of us now stare directly into the eyes of police brutality's harsh existence, the same existence that Black people have known to be true their entire lives.

The reignition of the Black Lives Matter movement was undoubtedly justifiable, expected and necessary in the aftermath of George Floyd's murder. As the movement gains steam, it forces us to have difficult conversations and continue to stare into the eyes of police brutality. 

Naturally, the recent movement has stirred up intense passion, coupled with anger and frustration — which is a good thing. How could someone watch the horrific video of George Floyd's murder and not be angry? 

The burning desire that many Americans have to argue in bad faith with each other is unhealthy, and prevents the implementation of practical solutions. We've seen this desire play out as “cancel culture's” recent growth has swarmed and infested public and private life. 

We should take solace in the fact that virtually all Americans agree — police brutality is a problem, and police reform is necessary. The idea that a vast swath of the country rejects this idea is unfounded. A CBS News poll recently found that 91% of Americans believe that police reform is necessary. We have been witnesses to the spawning of a significant culture shift in our country, and that's a good thing. 

The vast majority of Americans believe that if we want communities, particularly the African American community, to feel protected against gross negligence and abuse of power, police reform must be pursued and enacted. While many understand the issue, discourse begins by deliberating the solutions to the problem.

It is uncommon for the rural and suburban communities of Wisconsin to share the grievances of the Milwaukee and Madison areas, but the issue of police brutality has transcended these typically divergent communities. 

The movement against police brutality has occurred across the entire state since the death of George Floyd. The grievances against police brutality are not limited to Milwaukee and Madison area residents, as towns across the state such as Oshkosh, Appleton, Platteville and Kenosha have seen residents join in the fight against police brutality. 

Since this issue is not specific to any part of the state, the state's Assembly, Senate and Governor must work with each other to address police brutality. People can post on their Instagram stories all they want — but no structural change will be created without thoughtful, comprehensive legislation at the state level. 

So, what should police reform look like?

The call to "Defund the Police" has been thrust into the forefront of the police reform debate.

In Milwaukee and Madison, street murals reading "Defund the Police" have been painted in giant yellow letters on major city streets. The Milwaukee Common Council is exploring a 10% budget reduction to the police department that would amount to a nearly 30-million-dollar budget cut. State Rep. David Bowen, (D-Milwaukee), and State Rep. Jonathan Brostoff, (D-Milwaukee) have come out in support of Defunding the Police. 

Enjoy what you're reading? Get content from The Daily Cardinal delivered to your inbox

This is a bad idea. The majority of the money allotted to police budgets goes towards the officer's salaries, and those officers would likely bear the brunt of those budget cuts. If we decide to pay our officers less, they have less incentive to do their job well. If we pay officers more, they have an incentive to perform at a high level in efforts to maintain a high paying job. The National Economic Bureau even found statistical evidence that when officers are paid more, their performance increases. 

If we're expecting police officers to be better, why would we be taking money away from them? When schools are failing, we don't "Defund Schools," we give them more money and implement new plans to ensure their success. The City of Milwaukee has been defunding the police department for years. This past year the city cut the department's budget by 60 officers, and the homicide rate in Milwaukee has more than doubled. 

We should increase funding for police departments. The solution to police brutality is better policing; not less policing. We should be training our officers more. By paying more and training more, we can improve the performance of our local police officers. 

In addition to increasing funding for police departments, the state should extend Act 10 to cover police unions. Police unions present the same danger that other public sector unions present — they place their members' interests over the broader community. Police unions around the country have lobbied against greater transparency in day-to-day policing, public record laws that would make filed complaints against officers' public, merit-based pay and banning contracts with private trainers. 

Former Gov. Scott Walker (R-Wisconsin), passed the controversial union reform Act in 2011, however, the act did not apply to police unions. The Act restricted collective bargaining, ended mandatory union dues and required contributions to benefits. The implementation of Act 10 allowed school districts to evaluate teacher's disciplinary decisions on an individual basis and not worry about letting a lousy teacher go even if they had tenure. The same would be true if Act 10 were extended to police unions. Instead of an officer being shielded by the union, the department could evaluate disciplinary decisions on an individual basis and have the ability to fire the officer for any wrongdoing. 

Under the Milwaukee Police Union contract, officers can only be interrogated during certain hours of the day, which leaves the officers time to get their story straight. Last year, 93 Milwaukee police officers were disciplined for egregious misconduct, but all kept their jobs. If Act 10 were extended to police unions, it would have the same effect that it’s had on teachers' unions. It would provide departments the ability to promote their officers based on performance, not age. Along with the ability to individually evaluate the misconduct of their officers without police union protection. All in all, extending Act 10 to police unions would make for a more accountable and effective police force. 

As we continue to stare directly into the eyes of police brutality's harsh existence, let's continue to fight for solutions. Let's increase training and funding for police while extending Act 10 to cover police unions. By creating a more prepared, effective and accountable police force, we can take the first step in helping the African American community feel protected against abuse of power from which George Floyd suffered.

Tripp is a Sophomore studying Political Science. Do you think the police should receive additional training? Send all comments to

Support your local paper
Donate Today
The Daily Cardinal has been covering the University and Madison community since 1892. Please consider giving today.

Powered by SNworks Solutions by The State News
All Content © 2024 The Daily Cardinal