State Street does not need more bars.
On the surface, that is a great argument against welcoming Madhatters to join the street's alcohol lineup.
Businesses and property owners neighboring the 651 State St. property augmented this battle roar by arguing that another bar would increase violence, property damage and late- night disturbance. In response to the onslaught, Madhatters owner Ted Gervasi rescinded his liquor license application.
Gervasi made an earnest and significant effort to appease his potential State Street neighbors: He offered to compensate damages incurred by the bar's patrons, install increased security measures and comply with the Alcohol License Review Committee's conditions. These conditions mandated that Madhatters operate at a maximum capacity of 150, provide continuous food service and shut off the taps an hour before bar time.
The State Street property has earned a reputation for grand openings and rapid closings. Think Moe's and Fuddruckers. Madhatters lasted 20 years at its former location on University Avenue and is clearly a stable business. Stability is good for business in Madison and particularly on State Street.
Property owners and one-year tenants of the 600 block of State Street denied a business that would have brought stability to a location unfamiliar with the concept in recent years. His concessions spurned, Gervasi said he would not want to abide by any of the ALRC's conditions if he reopened off State Street.
Ultimately, student interest determines who sinks and who swims among downtown establishments.
As a known commodity, the bar should have been offered a fair opportunity to re-establish itself on campus.
